Sanibel Island, Florida golf home market

Median asking price
$1.4M
239%above golf homes in Florida
Price per sq ft
$547
135%above golf homes in Florida
Median sold price
$1.2M
14 sales in the last 12 months
Homes for sale
35
across 1 golf club
Typical days on market
37
3%below golf homes in Florida

Inventory as of September 2026

Median sold price

by quarter sold · Sanibel Island, Florida

Not available

14 sales in the last 12 months. A quarterly line needs at least 20 — below that each point moves on one or two transactions and the shape is noise, not a trend. 27 recorded over three years.

Market sentiment

35 homes listed, selling about 1.2 a month — enough inventory for 30 months.

Sanibel Island, Florida holds 30 months of supply — Among the highest-supply golf markets. Less supply favours sellers, more favours buyers. The needle's position is roughly this market's rank among golf markets. ← Favours sellersFavours buyers →

Among the highest-supply golf markets30 months of supply

55% more supply than US golf homes — buyers have more choice here, sellers more competition.

Bands come from the spread of every golf market we measure, not the general US housing convention.

Homes by price

35 golf-community homes for sale in Sanibel Island, Florida

  • $500K–$750K26%
  • $750K–$1M514%
  • $1M–$1.5M1543%
  • $1.5M–$2M823%
  • $2M–$3M514%

Distribution of golf-community homes for sale across price bands in Sanibel Island, Florida. $500K–$750K: 2 homes. $750K–$1M: 5 homes. $1M–$1.5M: 15 homes. $1.5M–$2M: 8 homes. $2M–$3M: 5 homes.

How golf homes in Sanibel Island, FL compare

The bar is golf homes in Sanibel Island, FL; the marks are wider golf markets on the same scale.

Median asking price by golf market$1.4M$535K US$410K FL
Price per sq ft by golf market$547$237 US$232 FL
View as table
MarketMedian asking price by golf marketPrice per sq ft by golf market
golf homes in Sanibel Island, FL$1.4M$547
golf homes in Florida$410K$232
US golf homes$535K$237

Homes for sale near Sanibel Island

205 homes

23810 Tuscany WAY — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23810 Tuscany WAY

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

4 bd · 6 ba · 5,414 sq ft

$3,299,000

23850 Messina CT — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23850 Messina CT

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

4 bd · 6 ba · 4,991 sq ft

$3,395,000

23709 Trevi CT — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23709 Trevi CT

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 4 ba · 3,199 sq ft

$1,875,000

24000 Tuscany CT — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

24000 Tuscany CT

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

4 bd · 5 ba · 5,377 sq ft

$5,950,000

23821 Merano CT #202 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23821 Merano CT #202

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,748 sq ft

$889,000

24041 Tuscany CT — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

24041 Tuscany CT

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

4 bd · 5 ba · 5,406 sq ft

$4,499,000

23850 Via Italia CIR #2004 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23850 Via Italia CIR #2004

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,085 sq ft

$1,299,000

23850 Via Italia CIR #2006 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23850 Via Italia CIR #2006

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,661 sq ft

$1,799,000

23850 Via Italia CIR #2005 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23850 Via Italia CIR #2005

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

2 bd · 3 ba · 2,273 sq ft

$1,250,000

23850 Via Italia CIR #805 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23850 Via Italia CIR #805

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,273 sq ft

$879,000

23850 Via Italia CIR #403 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23850 Via Italia CIR #403

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,086 sq ft

$819,000

23540 Via Veneto BLVD #602 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23540 Via Veneto BLVD #602

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,910 sq ft

$625,000

23850 Via Italia CIR #504 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23850 Via Italia CIR #504

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,086 sq ft

$799,000

24401 Terzetto LN #101 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

24401 Terzetto LN #101

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,117 sq ft

$1,085,000

4570 Colony Villas DR #3 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

4570 Colony Villas DR #3

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,656 sq ft

$1,495,000

23650 Via Veneto BLVD #404 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23650 Via Veneto BLVD #404

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,342 sq ft

$779,000

23650 VIA VENETO BLVD #503 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23650 VIA VENETO BLVD #503

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,930 sq ft

$669,000

23821 Tuscany CT — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23821 Tuscany CT

Estero, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

4 bd · 5 ba · 4,911 sq ft

$3,750,000

23650 Via Veneto #802 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23650 Via Veneto #802

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,818 sq ft

$724,900

4800 Pelican Colony BLVD #1003 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

4800 Pelican Colony BLVD #1003

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 4 ba · 3,315 sq ft

$2,499,000

4500 Seagrove Landing Way — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

4500 Seagrove Landing Way

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,305 sq ft

$1,765,000

4506 Seagrove Landing Way — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

4506 Seagrove Landing Way

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,305 sq ft

$1,785,000

23751 Merano CT #102 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23751 Merano CT #102

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,060 sq ft

$469,000

23750 Via Trevi WAY #2001 — The Colony Golf and Country Club The Colony Golf and Country Club

23750 Via Trevi WAY #2001

Bonita Springs, FL·13.6 mi from Sanibel Island

3 bd · 4 ba · 3,099 sq ft

$1,750,000